Moving boxes and plants in a bright home, ready for a downsizing move

Many longtime homeowners on the Monterey Peninsula stay in a house that no longer fits their life for one reason: they are afraid a move will mean a much higher property tax bill. If you are 55 or older, California's Proposition 19 may change that math. Here is a plain-English overview of what it allows, what it requires, and how to plan.

What Prop 19 allows

Approved by California voters in November 2020, Proposition 19 lets homeowners who are age 55 or older, or severely and permanently disabled at any age, transfer the taxable value of their primary residence to a replacement home, up to three times, anywhere in California. Your "taxable value" is the assessed value the county uses for your property taxes, which for longtime owners is often far below today's market value.

In other words, if you bought your Carmel, Pacific Grove or Salinas home decades ago, you may be able to keep a version of that lower tax base when you buy your next home, whether it is down the street, in another county or near the grandchildren.

How it works

  • Anywhere in California. Your replacement home does not need to be in Monterey County.
  • Up to three times. You can use the transfer up to three times in your lifetime, even if you used the older Prop 60/90 transfer before.
  • Any price. The new home can cost more than the one you sell. If it does, the difference in market value is added to the tax value you bring with you. If it costs the same or less, you generally keep your existing taxable value.
  • Timing. You must buy or build the replacement home within two years before or after selling your original home.
  • Primary residence. Both the home you sell and the home you buy must be your principal residence, eligible for the homeowners' exemption.
  • Age. You must be at least 55 when you sell your original home.

How to claim it

The transfer is not automatic. After you buy your replacement home, you file a claim with the county assessor where the new home is located, using form BOE-19-B, "Claim for Transfer of Base Year Value to Replacement Primary Residence for Persons at Least Age 55 Years." For a home in Monterey County, that is the Monterey County Assessor's Office. Filing deadlines affect whether the benefit applies from the start, so file promptly and keep copies of your closing documents.

A quick example

Suppose a couple in their 70s sell a longtime family home whose assessed value is $400,000 but whose market value is $1.8 million, and they buy a single-level home for $1.5 million. Because the new home costs less than the one they sold, they can generally keep a taxable value close to their old $400,000 base, rather than being reassessed at $1.5 million. If instead they bought a $2 million home, the $200,000 difference would be added to their transferred value.

Illustration only. Actual figures depend on your situation and on the county assessor's determination.

What Prop 19 changed for inherited homes

Prop 19 also narrowed the parent-to-child exclusion. Today, a child can generally keep a parent's lower tax base only on a family home that the child makes their own primary residence, and only up to a value limit; homes kept as rentals or second homes are typically reassessed. If your plan is to leave your home to your children, it is worth discussing the options with an estate planning attorney now. As a Seniors Real Estate Specialist®, Barbara works alongside families, trustees and attorneys when an inherited home is sold.

Planning tips before you move

  1. Talk to a tax professional first. Property taxes, capital gains and estate planning all interact. A CPA or attorney can help you see the full picture.
  2. Know your numbers. Your current assessed value is on your property tax bill. A home valuation shows what your home could sell for today.
  3. Mind the two-year window. Decide whether you want to buy first or sell first, and plan your timeline so both happen within two years.
  4. Think about the right next home. Single-level living, less maintenance, closer to family or medical care: the right fit matters more than the address.
  5. Plan the move itself. Downsizing decades of belongings takes time. Barbara can connect you with trusted move managers, estate sale professionals, contractors and stagers.

Let's plan your next chapter together

Barbara J. Weidman is a REALTOR® and Seniors Real Estate Specialist® (SRES®) with Compass who helps Monterey County homeowners and their families plan later-life moves with patience and care. A conversation costs nothing and commits you to nothing. Learn about Barbara's senior transition services.

Contact BarbaraWhat's My Home Worth?

Or call (831) 254-6559.

This article is general information, not tax or legal advice. Rules and forms can change; confirm details with the Monterey County Assessor's Office, the California State Board of Equalization (boe.ca.gov/prop19) and your own tax or legal advisor before making decisions.

Photo: Dina Badamshina via Unsplash.